Who do you think would win Samoan Bulldozer Umaga or Samoa Joe from TNA?
the samoan bulldozer would chew joe up and spit him out umaga isn't much of a wrestler but samoa joe has not wrestling ability at all. and talent the only way joe knows anything about talent is what he looked up about it in the dictionary.
J-Kidd is an idiot. If he knew the history they would know that the WWE copied Samoa Joe's character because they couldn't sign him to the WWE before TNA did so they picked someone whom they already fired (TNA fired as well) under the name Jamal when he was a part of 3 Minute Warning. This isn't unusual for WWE, Vince did the same thing when he couldn't sign the Legion of Doom until later so, because he refuses to be outdone, puts a half-assed team (like Umaga is a half-assed wrestler) in the ring and call them the greatest. Hell, Vince even copied Samoa Joe's undefeated streak. To answer your question, Umaga wouldn't stand a chance against Samoa Joe. Samoa Joe is one of the few big men in history that is not only strong, but technically sound, has great submission skills (hence the name Samoan Submission Machine, he is quick and agile for a guy his size, and he has great aerial skills (he can run and do a suicide dive over the top rope and to the outside and he is 300 pounds!). The truth is that cheap excuse for a copy Umaga isn't in the same league as Samoa Joe and I am a WWE fan as well as a TNA fan and I mention that because anybody who would say Umaga would win obviously has never watched TNA. Oh, and cpr_dummy, Samoa Joe won the won the Most Outstanding Wrestler Award in 2005 and has 4 5 Star Matches (most only have one and only Chris Benoit and Kurt Angle of the WWE has more that still currently wrestles) from the Wrestling Observer Newsletter and they judge wrestlers on their ability not on how they do that year because they were being pushed like Pro Wresling Magazine does, maybe you should watch the match that Samoa Joe had with Kurt Angle before you talk cpr_dummy, Bret Hart said he hasn't seen a better match in a while.
I don't even watch TNA and I would say the Bulldozer. Umaga is a cheap gimmick and I've thought so since the day he came up. He's got damn near no actual moves and the only thing he can do is throw his weight around. I've seen and heard great things about Joe.
