To identify a high-quality aluminum coil, consider the following factors: purity level, which should be 99.5% or higher for most applications; surface finish, ensuring it's smooth and free from defects; thickness consistency, which should be uniform across the entire coil; mechanical properties, such as tensile strength and elongation, that meet industry standards; and adherence to specific alloy grades for particular applications. Additionally, check for certifications from recognized standards organizations and consider the supplier's reputation for quality and consistency.