Home > categories > Rubber & Plastics > Agricultural Plastic Products > Is plastic bags really better than recycled paper bags?
Question:

Is plastic bags really better than recycled paper bags?

When offered a choice, most request plastic over paper and usually make a smart alec comment like, quot;Save a treequot;. But it's recycled paper. Isn't the plastic factory ruining the environment worse than the paper plant?

Answer:

To me they are cuz when we come from the store with a plastic bag. we use them for something else later.
Just given the choice of paper or plastic - plastic is better - I did a study and paper uses more oil and causes pollution of rivers and air.
I've just recently read that, as far as how much energy it takes to make them, the difference is negligible. However, plastics will never biodegrade, while paper has a chance. The best thing is to bring your own bag, and avoid the whole thing altogether.
I absolutely support it. But I am not in favor of using the paper bags either. Buy some eco-friendly re-usable bags that you can take with you grocery shopping. They have a much larger capacity than the standard plastic and paper bags and can be washed and reused for years. Plus no more plastic bas at the landfill. Think about how many plastic bags you go home with every time you grocery shop. Now think of all those bags clogging the landfills and our streets..... ICKY..... Be the change you want to see in the world!!!!
Hemp, cotton and canvas bags are the best. Plastic Bags: There are a lot of reasons given why people 'like' plastic bags. However, they still never decompose no matter how many times you use them. This is compounded when people tie their rubbish into plastic bags. If you insist on using plastic bags you will be charged high taxes for doing so. So re-use as many times as possible then take them supermarket to be recycled. Biodegradeable Bags/Bioplastics: Polylactic acid (PLA) a biodegradable polymer derived from lactic acid. These vegetable based bioplastics biodegrades quickly under composting conditions and does not leave toxic residue. However, bioplastic have own environmental impacts caused by manufacturing and disposal of end product. Again you will be charged for these impacts and taxed but on the plus side biodegradable bags (from potato and corn starches) are a new thriving industry Paper Bags. Great if singly composted. In land fill can take years for layers to decompose. Still an organic material. But there is cost of production, costs to environment of pulp trees (monocultures, loss of habitat, etc) costs of recycling/disposal. Again you will have to pay for these production costs and disposal costs and taxed. In UK instead of stop supplying plastic bags you get rewards for bringing your own. Money back, green points. Even with supermarket home delivery See Tesco. This has not been effective so we are back to taxes. In New Zealand Cloth bags are already promoted and sold in supermarkets. However this is not stopping plastic bag useage. France is banning plastic bags 2007 others are moving towards it. The most effective is taxing plastic bag use. If we do not take action we will be taxed as the Irish are for using plastic bags. Effective as a decrease of 90% plastic bag use in Ireland.

Share to: