Home > categories > Machinery & Equipment > Crusher > Which is a better mascara: Maybelline One by One or CoverGirl Lash Exact?
Question:

Which is a better mascara: Maybelline One by One or CoverGirl Lash Exact?

I've tried Falsies (it was a major disappointment) and I have CoverGirl Clump Crusher Extensions. I love the Clump Crusher because it's true to its name and because of that it's low maintenance, but it gives me no length. I'm not worried about volume as much as I am length, and I was looking at these two mascaras. My eyelashes are short, black, and naturally curled. I've been using Vaseline on them and now the bottom lashes are almost as long as the top ones, while the top ones don't seem to have grown yet. Which mascara is better for lengthening? And if neither of these are best, please suggest some more inexpensive drugstore mascaras.

Answer:

Non of those. I tried both and I didn't like them very much. Try colossal by Maybelline, I like that one.
Hello and thank you for calling the Mascara Queen. LOL Wagreen's lets you return make up if you don't like it. For awhile I was switching mascaras every couple of weeks and they were teasing me! LOL So, I am saying I want the same out of mascara that you do and have tried several kind. (I returned the Clump Crusher) For months I was very happy with Lash Stiletto. Then my daughter turned me on to Maybelline Colossal volume express - Cat Eyes. (yellow tube with cheetah print) This has been my new favorite for months now. Sometimes I can work them all the way to my brows almost. A trick I use after I have had the mascara a while, is to wipe the brush clean. It gets out all the older gluck and puts on all new. I notice when it stops working as well, it has been at least 3 months or more and it is time to replace it. TRY IT, TRY IT ! I LOVE IT, LOVE IT !!! Go to some place like Walgreens where if you keep your recpt, you can bring it back when ever you want. Hope this helps!

Share to: