A GeForce 6800 GT or the ultra version of the card.
Ultra will give some difference in performance... but doesn't it just have more memory? If so that just means it will support higher resolutions. the 6800 series is very dated... If you could, I'd start in the 8000 series of card.. you'll just be asking this again before long otherwise. I went from the 6800 to the 7900 series a while ago and am still using it 6mos later.
The GeForce 6800 GT, it's one of the best around.
out of those 2, the particularly is an prolonged much greater useful suited. for particularly a on a similar time as, the 6800 particularly replaced into the suited available agp answer. although if, they stopped making the ultras an prolonged term interior the previous, so any which you detect are 2nd hand...and would not artwork. The gt had an prolonged production life and you are able to in spite of the actuality that discover those new. on a similar time as upgrading from a 5600 to any 6800 (no remember if that's gt or particularly) you will see an important overall performance enhance...even on a 4x bus. I as quickly as went from the 5500 to 6600 and the version replaced into night and day. one ingredient i could advise besides the actuality that young ones that, verify out the 7900gs and the ati x1950. those are the suited agp enjoying cards available and are stable performers.
out of those 2, the ultra is far better. For quite some time, the 6800 ultra was the best possible agp solution. However, they stopped making the ultras a long time ago, so any that you find are second hand...and may not work. The gt had a longer production life and you can still find those new. When upgrading from a 5600 to any 6800 (whether it is gt or ultra) you will notice a significant performance boost...even on a 4x bus. I once went from the 5500 to 6600 and the difference was night and day. One thing I might suggest though, check out the 7900gs and the ati x1950. These are the best agp cards available and are good performers.
Nvidia before has a classing of their cards comparable to the performance that you would generally see coming from them this classing goes as follows GS - GT - GTX (possibly) - ULTRA The Ultra series cards perform at a much higher level and are at the bleeding edge of that particulair processors speed.The only problem is that they might experience overheating or artifacting because of how far the cards Core and Memory speeds have been pushed. In a benchmark i would expect to see atleaset a 10 -20 % increase between the two cards. You should definitly see a marked increase from the upgrade. but do know that AGP is a dying socket that in many ways is still around, but is being slowly phased out by 16x PCI express. Overall the biggest bottleneck for you is going to come from your processor and the amount of ram you have. You should be able to play many games out today with this series card but it too is a dying breed and is soon becomeing a dinosaur.