Home > categories > Machinery & Equipment > Excavators > Rate and help me fix my MTG deck?
Question:

Rate and help me fix my MTG deck?

Creatures Air Elemental X2 Surrakar Banisher X1Wall of Frost X1 Drake Umbra X1 Plated Seastrider X1 Halimar Excavator X1 Cathartic Adept X1 Windrider Eel X1 Phantom Warrior X1 Mnemonic Wall X1 Wind Drake X1 Merfolk Looter X1 Caller of Gales X1 Kraken Hatchling X1 Jwari Scuttler X1 Snapping Drake X1 Serra Angel X2 Stormfront Pegasus X1 Leonin Arbiter X1 Platinum Angel X1 Linvala, Keeper of silence X1 White Knight X1 Blinding Mage X1 Soul Warden X1 Archon of Redemptiom X1 Lone Missionary X1 Goldenglow Moth X1 Perimeter Captain X1 Artifacts Couriers Capsule X1Marble Chalice X1Kitesail X1Grindclock X1Sorcery/Enchantments Pacifism X2 See Beyond X1 Cancel X2Essence Scatter X2 Diminish X1 Tome Scour X1 Telepathy X1 Sleep X1 Mind Control X1Unsummon X1 Divination X1Summoners Bane X1Day Of Judgment X1Soul Parry X1Dispense X1Fulgent Distraction X1Guardian Zendikon X1 Safe Passage X1Repel the Darkness X1 Lands Terramorphic Expanse X3 Island X10 Plains X10

Answer:

2/10 Your deck is way too random with no focus. Come up with a theme and stick to it
Way too random to be any good. Only a few multiples of cards and no real theme to the deck.
I like it 6 out of 10
i would run atleast one more doj, put in a couple (even a place set)of O ring add another terramorphic, and maybe seachrome coast or other dual lands. i would take out tome scour. it seems a common thing you are going for is control. i would stick to that and take out the mill that you have, as you don't have all that much. it has a good start to it, but the mill def. doesn't work, you need more place sets, and more dual lands i give it 6/10. still needs work but on its way :)
Um, this deck kinda sucks just from a quick glance. The first problem you have is that there are way too many one-ofs. Ask yourself, Self, what am I really trying to accomplish with this deck?. Then, find the cards that are essential to that idea and put 4 of them in. The creatures that you selected are mostly low-tier creatures. That is, you could find better creatures for the same price, if not cheaper. This is the same for your spells section. Your lands are decent. If you can, put in some dual lands, even tap duals would be good. Boreal Shelf, Celestial Colonade, Coastal Tower, etc. Overall, I would rate this as a 3/10. It falls into the beginner type decks (put cards that match the color I am going for into the deck and play.)

Share to: